Bloomberg sugary drink ban has powerful opponentsBy Nancy Watzman May 31 2012 2:37 p.m.
Mayor Michael Bloomberg's announcement that the city will pursue a ban on large sugary drinks sold at restaurants, movie theatres, and other locations is just the latest attempt in his campaign against obesity--one that has so far met with little success in the face of a powerful food lobby, one sometimes joined by odd bedfellows.
In 2010, when his administration asked the federal government for permission to prohibit New York City food stamp recipients from purchasing sugary drinks with their benefits, the Food Industry Alliance of New York State, a trade group representing New York State grocers and other retailers, was not pleased.
In a letter written to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) obtained by Sunlight via a Freedom of Information Act Request (FOIA), the group argued that Food Stamps recipients should be able to make their own nutritional choices just like anyone else and that banning one unhealthy food could become a slippery slope to excluding others.
"Once such a ... precedent is established, government could easily expand its perogative to other categories it deems "nutritionally questionable" (salt due to hypertension, saturated food due to heart disease, etc.)," wrote the trade group.
Also writing a letter was a group not associated with corporate lobbying -- the New York City Coalition Against Hunger. The group argued that the proposal "criminalizes hunger by eliminating the ability of low-income SNAP [food stamp] recipients to even occasionaly obtain sugar-sweetened beverages."
In August 2011, the USDA denied New York City's request for the waiver.
In 2010, Bloomberg also championed a penny-per-ounce tax on soda, which failed in the face of a lobbying campaign by the soda industry. Similar efforts in other 30 other states have been beaten back, including a recent effort to impose such a tax in Hawaii, reported Bloomberg News in March.
Search the Blog
Real Time Ticker
- IRS takes aim at $300 million campaign influence industry
- Happy Thankgiving! How does campaign cash affect the food on your plate?
- Christie brings his clout, fundraising chops to new role as RGA head
- Stockman campaign goes for campaign finance hat trick
- Bakers group happy to win exemption from food safety law
Reporting we're watching
- OpenSecrets: Millionaire Freshmen Make Congress Even Wealthier
- OpenSecrets: Chinese Telecom Firm Says It's Not Giving Up the Fight in Washington
- Sunlight Foundation: Today in #OpenGov 12/5/2013
- Sunlight Foundation: Montgomery County’s Open Data Town Hall, the Town Hall of the Future
- Sunlight Foundation: Scout Delivering Court Opinions Through the Awe-Inspiring Power of CourtListener